Showing posts with label CPR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CPR. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Family Presence During CPR

The majority of EMS providers have experience, in one role or another, in providing real-life CPR. Anyone who has knows the following five things:

1) CPR is chaotic and often confusing, even for trained professionals.
2) It is a violent and ugly spectacle replete with torn clothing, cracked ribs and vomit. The patient's body is battered by tubes, needles and electrical shocks.
3) It has nowhere near the success rate that TV leads our patient population to expect.
4) Successful resuscitation in the field doesn't mean they'll survive their time in the hospital, let alone be discharged with the same level of neurological and physical function.
5) EMS providers often begin CPR without the faintest glimmer of hope.

Aside from following protocol, it seems we are often motivated to perform CPR in order to be able to look the patient's family in the eyes and honestly tell them, "We did everything we could." This has led to a real question, both within EMS and in hospital environments- should family members be allowed to witness the chaotic, technical and often nauseating moments that constitute the end of their loved one's lives?

There has a been a lot of qualitative research (or subjective, if you want to be judgmental) done on this subject. There's no real agreement; some medical professionals think it aids in the healing process, others think it complicates the grieving process unnecessarily. The same thing goes for patient's families, although few ever think about it until they're faced with the decision.

I'd like to post a couple different points of view on this, both from EMS providers and the general public. So...what do you think? Leave a comment or drop me a line on Twitter @squirrel325. I'm interested to hear your thoughts.